Review

Mid Wales Opera's Eugene Onegin is a sterling effort - review 

Mid Wales Opera perform Eugene Onegin
Mid Wales Opera perform Eugene Onegin Credit: Mid Wales Opera

Touring opera round smaller venues outside metropolitan areas is a heroic adventure – some might say a fool's one too – and Mid Wales Opera deserves medals for its continuing efforts on this front. Over the years I’ve admired and enjoyed its marvellously fresh and zippy stagings of Falstaff, Albert Herring, The Tales of Hoffmann (among others), presented in far-flung towns to appreciative audiences that wouldn’t otherwise see such things live. One only hopes that the relevant funding bodies continue to see the value of the exercise.

Alas, this perfectly decent new production of Tchaikovsky’s Eugene Onegin isn’t vintage. Richard Studer designs and directs, playing it very straight and providing no special insight or sensitivity to the currents of the drama. His sensitively lit set, graced with Regency period costuming, is simple and efficient, but there’s no thrust to the action or focus to the characterisation. Although the motions are dutifully gone through, nothing has been pushed or explored. Particularly feeble are the three danced scenes, which badly need the energising services of a choreographer or specialist movement director.

Jonathan Lyness, Studer’s regular collaborator at the Longborough Festival, conducts the chamber orchestra Ensemble Cymru in a steady account of the lyrical score: they do a good job, but this is maturely romantic music for which one craves a richer weightier string sound than can be provided by two fiddles, viola and cello.

The voices do something to compensate. George von Bergen, formerly an ENO stalwart, makes a saturnine Onegin, robust in tone and dashing of demeanour. His Tatyana is Elizabeth Karani: she fields a warm and secure soprano, but she won’t melt our hearts until she lets it rip more in the letter scene and the final showdown. Robyn Lyn Evans relishes Lensky’s woes and Sion Goronwy gives a gravely sympathetic account of Gremin’s sentimental aria. The smaller roles are notably well taken.

The text is clearly articulated without surtitles through David Lloyd-Jones’ translation and rightly played for once with two short intervals, indicative of the story’s time lapses. It’s not in sum a strikingly original or musically distinguished account of the opera, but I wouldn’t want to leave too negative an impression. Given the limited budget and the pressures of a whistle-stop schedule, it’s a sterling effort that will give honest pleasure on its forthcoming spring tour.

Until 10 April. Information about the tour 01686 614563; www.midwalesopera.co.uk

License this content